1911-1912 Alfred Stillman
1913 George Whitney
1914 Alfred Stillman
1915-1917 Eric S. Winston
1918 Fillmore Van S. Hyde
1919 John W. Appel, Jr.
1920 Auguste J. Cordier
1921 Fillmore Van S. Hyde
1922 Thomas R. Coward
1923 R. Earl Fink
1924 Fillmore Van S. Hyde
1925 William Rand, Jr.
1926 Fillmore Van S. Hyde
1927-1929 Rowland B. Haines
1930-1940 Harry F. Wolf
1941 T. A. E. Harris
1942-1945 (no tournaments held)
1946 Frank R. Hanson
1947 Frederick B. Ryan, Jr.
1948-1950 H. Robert Reeve
1951 J. T. P. Sullivan
1952 H. Robert Reeve
1953 Howard J. Rose
1954-1956 H. Robert Reeve
1957-1959 J. Lennox Porter
1960-1962 James Prigoff
1963 John Powers
1964 James Prigoff
1965 (no tournament held)