The Meaning of Good—A Dialogue by Goldsworthy Lowes Dickinson
page 49 of 247 (19%)
page 49 of 247 (19%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
"Do you mean to say, then," said Leslie, "that because this instinct is so strong therefore it is always good to follow it?" "I should say so, generally speaking." "How is it, then, that you consider it disgraceful that a man should run away in battle?" "Ah!" replied Parry, "that is a very interesting point! There you get a superposition of the social upon the merely individual instinct." "And how does that come about?" "That may be a matter of some dispute; but it has been ingeniously explained as follows. We start with the primary instinct of self-preservation. This means, at first, that each individual strives to preserve himself. But as time goes on individuals discover that they can only preserve themselves by associating with others, and that they must defend society if they want to defend themselves. They thus form a habit of defending society; and this habit becomes in time a second instinct, and an instinct so strong that it even overrides the primary one from which it was derived; till at last you get individuals sacrificing in defence of the community those very lives which they originally entered the community to preserve." "What a charming paradox!" cried Ellis. "And so it is really true that every soldier who dies on the field of battle does so only by virtue of a miscalculation? And if he could but pull himself up and remember that, after all, the preservation of his life was the only motive that |
|