Edward MacDowell by John F. Porte
page 37 of 159 (23%)
page 37 of 159 (23%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
|
Destroyed by the Composer. OPUS 9. TWO OLD SONGS, FOR VOICE AND PIANOFORTE. _First Published_, 1894. (Arthur P. Schmidt). 1. _Deserted_. 2. _Slumber Song_. The _Two Old Songs, Op. 9_, head the list of MacDowell's published works with opus numbers. Their position in it, however, is somewhat misleading to the casual observer of the composer's artistic development, for they are the fruits of a mature period and were given the opus number they bear only as a matter of convenience. They were composed about ten or eleven years after the songs of Ops. 11 and 12, which in comparison with the _Two Old, Songs_ are weak and devoid of individuality and originality. The _Two Old Songs_ are very beautiful and expressive, exhibiting the composer's melodic gift. _Deserted_ is a setting of Robert Burns's lines, "Ye banks and braes o' bonnie Doon." It is one of the most expressive of MacDowell's songs, being full of deep and very human pathos. The melody is one of the most poignant he set down, but it is subjected to repetition that becomes monotonous. The song is expressively indicated _Slow: With pathos, yet simply_. |
|


