The Tattva-Muktavali by Purnananda Chakravartin
page 17 of 31 (54%)
page 17 of 31 (54%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
Sa"nkara quotes the passage from the Bhagavad Gita (xviii. 61),
"The Lord of all beings abides in the region of the heart,--causing all beings to revolve by his illusion as though mounted on a machine."]; thus their difference is proved to be essential. If it were not so, how could the Commentator have used such an expression as "the worshipper" and "the worshipped" [Footnote: He uses this very expression __upasyopasakabhava__ in his Comment. on i. 2. 4.]? 61. I am sometimes happy, sometimes miserable; He, the supreme Soul, is always essentially happy. Such is the difference,--then how can there be identity between these two different substances? 62. He is eternally self-luminous and unobscured,-- intensely pure, the one witness of the world; not so is the individual soul,--thus a thunderbolt falls on the tree of the theory of Identity. 63. For those who maintain the identity of the individual and supreme soul, the hypothesis of a __dvandva compound__ [Footnote: __I.e.__ in the word __jivatmanau__] is precluded; or they bring forward such words as __d.rishadupala__ as parallel cases [Footnote: I suppose that this means that the __dvandva__ compound __d.rishadupala__ has some analogy to one like __jivatmanau__, which involves identity, as the upper and lower millstone form one instrument; but there (in accordance with Pa.n. 2. 2. 34, __vartt.__) the less important word meaning the upper and smaller stone (__upala__) is placed last (cf. 2. 2. 31)]; the __dvandva__ is only consistent with "difference," but in no way with "identity." 64. Where identity is the meaning, there arises the __karmadharaya__ compound,--for [such a __karmadharaya__ as] __nilotpala__ "the |
|